Campus and Community

Ask the Expert: Understanding the Pope’s Resignation

By: Mary Ann Cozza

cuevae_chair

Professor Ed Cueva

With news of Pope Benedict XVI’s resignation still fresh in the minds of  Catholics worldwide, Skyline asked an expert to explain the processes of papal resignation and election. Ed Cueva, chair of the Arts & Humanities Department, and professor and scholar of the Classics and religion, served as our expert this week.

MC: Dr. Cueva, please explain to our readers the significance of Pope Benedict’s resignation. 

Cueva: It was very shocking and surprising that the Holy Father resigned. It has been roughly 600 years since the last papal resignation, which was forced in order to settle the Western Schism when two men claimed to be Pope and the church was in upheaval. There have been less than nine papal resignations in history, so it’s a very unusual occurrence. One of the most famous popes to resign was Pope Celestine V in 1294. He stepped down after five months in the position and after passing a law that made papal resignation legal. His resignation led him to be vilified by Dante Alighieri in his work “The Divine Comedy” –

I saw and recognized the shade of him
Who by his cowardice made the great refusal.

—Inferno III, 59–60

MC: What are the next steps to electing a successor for Pope Benedict?

Cueva: Pope Benedict will officially step down at 8 p.m. Feb. 28. pope-benedict-stockAt this point, the College of Cardinals (senior officials) have 15 to 20 days to gather at the Sistine Chapel and enter into Conclave, the official ceremony of electing a new pope. Conclave is very secretive and ritualistic. Cardinals must vote in a two-thirds majority, plus one, to elect the next pope. After each vote, the ballots are lit on fire and mixed with certain chemicals. The world will watch the smoke from the Chapel, as it indicates the result of the vote: dark smoke means no consensus was met, while white smoke signals a new pope was elected.

MC: Is it known why Pope Benedict resigned?

Cueva: In his resignation address, given in Latin, Pope Benedict cited his deteriorating health for the resignation. Its believed that as a trusted advisor of his predecessor Pope John Paul II, Pope Benedict witnessed the decline of his health and didn’t want to put the church through that turmoil again.

MC: Is there speculation as to who might succeed Pope Benedict?

Cueva: There is a saying that “Those who enter the Sistine Chapel as Pope, leave as Cardinals” – meaning that the front runners for the papacy usually aren’t the ones that are selected. Traditionally, the College of Cardinals look for cardinals who have spent large quantities of time in the Vatican, represent large diocese and are from leading European countries – Italy, Austria, Spain, etc. But truthfully, it could be anyone and in fact, Cardinal Daniel DiNardo, the Archbishop of Galveston-Houston, was named one of the people to watch. It will definitely be interesting to see who is selected. It’s a very exciting time!